Tim Ash: CBRT indecision could prove costly

As expected the CBRT’s MPC kept policy rates unchanged at 37%. But given geopolitical trends I think that was a mistake.

CBRT MPC statement is here:

https://www.tcmb.gov.tr/wps/wcm/connect/en/tcmb+en/main+menu/announcements/press+releases/2026/ano2026-12

Actually prior inflation trends – with inflation doggedly holding above 30% – suggested that the prudent move should have been at the least a hold. But then add on the extreme geopolitical risks now emanating from the war in Iran and this should have encouraged a further policy tightening – a rate hike – in my view.

It’s a cop out to say that there are uncertain risks coming out of the Gulf so let’s wait and see. This is the biggest crisis in the Gulf since the 70s. Oil prices are already higher by at least $30 than at the outset of this crisis. And the consensus is that Turkiye is amongst the most vulnerable EM countries to higher energy prices as it’s still a huge energy importer. A rough rule of thumb is each 10 buck increase in the oil price adds $3bn to the current account deficit and 1.2% to inflation. So at $100 oil that’s already a 3.6% hit to inflation and at least $9bn to the current account deficit. And the current account deficit was already expected to reach $30 billion this year so now more likely this will be $40 billion best case. And this does not take account of all the other supply chain disruptions coming from the Gulf which will likely hike prices across a range on inputs imported by Turkiye from fertilizer to helium. But even then it’s very likely that the current oil price will not be the peak.

This crisis looks still set on an escalation path – the Islamic Republic appears to have found Trump’s TACO choke point and are likely to extend the war until they gat assurances of no more future attacks, sanctions relief and economic assistance. They will play hard ball, attacking the Strsits and the Gulf until then. Indeed, I think it is more likely we see oil hit $150 a barrel from here, not $70. Imagine that – a further $15 billion hit then to the current account deficit taking it to $50 billion plus, and 7% plus more to inflation. You could probably then argue that at $150 oil we are in global systemic crisis mode and most central banks in EM will be hiking rates. But I think the prudent thing for any central banks to do is plan for the worst case not take a let’s just wait and see approach.

And for Turkiye it is not just about inflation but broader macro-financial stability and the real exchange rate anchor for inflation. Already the CBRT has had to use a weight of FX reserves defending the lira against the shock from the war in Iran – perhaps as much as $20 billion. Now while FX reserves are close to record highs, they are not finite and a pre-emptive policy rate hike would have sent a strong positive signal to the market and likely stemming selling pressure on the lira and FX reserve loss.

ANALYSIS: Current Account Deficit Widens and Reserves Dip, but Financing Remains Abundant

And in the circumstances I think no one would have blamed the CBRT for hiking policy rates in response to geopolitical risk. And if they (and me) ended up being wrong on geopolitical risk in Iran and oil prices don’t stay elevated for long they will have got ahead of the curve in the important longer term fight against inflation. Indeed, no one blamed the CBRT for their emergency policy rates hike last March in response to the surprise arrest of Istanbul mayor Imamoglu. Indeed, the CBRT actions then helped stabilise the political economy. I think a hike this time around would have also sent a strong message of reassurance in deeply worrying times. An opportunity was missed in my mind.

This is an excerpt, pls read read Tim Ash blogs clicking this link

PA Turkey intends to inform Turkey watchers with diverse views and opinions. Articles in our website may not necessarily represent the view of our editorial board or count as endorsement.

Follow our English YouTube channel (REAL TURKEY):
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKpFJB4GFiNkhmpVZQ_d9Rg

Twitter: @AtillaEng
Facebook: Real Turkey Channel: https://www.facebook.com/realturkeychannel/